https://doi.org/10.22364/iscflul.10.20 | 270-281 | PDF
Raimondas Andrijauskas, Master of Law (PhD student)
Mykolas Romeris University, Lithuania
In Search of a Balance: Personal Data Protection During Extraordinary Situations
Key words: personal data protection, extraordinary situations, proportionality principle
Summary
The Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union recognises the protection of personal data as a fundamental right (Article 8). Recent extraordinary situations in Europe – including the migration and refugee crisis, terrorist attacks, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the war in Ukraine – have prompted EU Member States to adopt emergency measures relying extensively on digital technologies, such as real-time facial recognition systems, contact-tracing and location-tracking applications, and large-scale health data processing mechanisms.
While these measures are frequently justified by urgent public-interest objectives, they raise serious concerns regarding their legality, necessity, and proportionality. Emergency responses are often characterised by accelerated decision-making, limited ex ante impact assessments, and reduced public scrutiny, increasing the risk that temporary measures may outlast the extraordinary situations that justified their adoption. As a result, such practices may lead to disproportionate interferences with the fundamental right to personal data protection, particularly affecting vulnerable or marginalised groups.
This research examines the relationship between extraordinary legal regimes and personal data protection within EU Member States. It addresses the challenges of assessing the proportionality of emergency data processing measures, noting that systematic judicial analysis in this area remains limited. By analysing decisions of constitutional and administrative courts concerning extraordinary data processing measures challenged by individuals or political actors, the study identifies emerging judicial standards for reviewing governmental actions that restrict the right to personal data protection.
The research contributes to both academic discourse and practical governance by proposing a framework for safeguarding core data-protection principles during crises. By synthesising judicial reasoning and best practices derived from case law, it offers guidance for ensuring that emergency measures remain lawful, proportionate, time-limited, and respectful of the essence of fundamental rights.
Published in: National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective. Proceedings of the 10th International Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Law of the University of Latvia, 6–7 November 2025. Riga: University of Latvia Press, 2026. ISBN 978-9934-36-688-8.