https://doi.org/10.22364/iscflul.10.26 | 351-362 | PDF

Piia Kalamees, PhD, Associate Professor
University of Tartu, Estonia

Kalev Saare, Dr. iur., Visiting Professor
Tallinn University, Estonia

The Impact of the CJEU’s Case Law on Unfair Contract Terms and Responsible Lending on the res judicata Principle in Estonian Law

Key words: unfair contract terms, principle of responsible lending, res judicata principle, consumer law

Summary
The CJEU has consistently held that, while res judicata serves legal certainty and the proper administration of justice, national procedural rules must nevertheless comply with the principles of equivalence and effectiveness. Accordingly, the CJEU requires national courts to examine ex officio both the unfairness of standard contract terms under Directive 93/13/EEC and compliance with the creditor’s creditworthiness assessment obligations under Directive 2008/48/EC. Where such a review has not been conducted prior to the finality of a judgment, EU law requires that it be possible to carry it out in subsequent proceedings, a requirement that Estonian law does not always satisfy.
The authors of this paper analyse the effect of the CJEU practice on Estonian civil, bankruptcy and enforcement procedures. It demonstrates that the review of final judgments – the only mechanism in Estonian law capable of retroactively removing the effects of res judicata – is unavailable where the relevant circumstances existed at the time of the original decision. As EU law does not oblige national courts to interpret domestic law contra legem, effective consumer-protection review must instead be ensured in enforcement proceedings or other subsequent and separate procedures.
Although Estonian enforcement law does not expressly permit deviation from res judicata, such deviation is possible through interpretation, particularly under § 221 of the Code of Enforcement Procedure. By contrast, bankruptcy proceedings reveal a direct conflict: Estonian law mandates the unconditional recognition of claims based on final judgments, thereby excluding any review for consumer protection. This approach is incompatible with CJEU case law and calls for legislative amendment.


Published in: National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective. Proceedings of the 10th International Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Law of the University of Latvia, 6–7 November 2025. Riga: University of Latvia Press, 2026. ISBN 978-9934-36-688-8.