https://doi.org/10.22364/iscflul.10.01 | 10-19 | PDF
Irena Kucina, Dr. iur., Associate Professor
President, Constitutional Court of the Republic of Latvia
Martin Kuijer, Dr.
Vice-president, European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission), Judge, Hoge Raad der Nederlanden (Supreme Court of the Netherlands)
National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective
Key words: Dutch and Latvian perspectives, relationship between the EU legal order and national law, openness to international law, basic principles of EU law, principle of loyal cooperation, General Data Protection Regulation, Court of Justice of the European Union, European Central Bank, Constitutional Court of Latvia, Supreme Court of Netherlands, recent case law, fundamental rights, European Convention on Human Rights, “Self-executing” provisions
Summary
This article examines the interaction between national legal systems and European Union law from a comparative Latvian and Dutch perspective. It argues that, despite different constitutional arrangements, constitutional and supreme courts perform a common function: translating the European legal acquis into the national legal order while ensuring effective protection of fundamental rights.
The Latvian perspective is illustrated through the principle of loyal cooperation, as applied in the case law of the Constitutional Court of Latvia, particularly in cases concerning data protection under the General Data Protection Regulation and the duty to consult the European Central Bank. The Dutch perspective demonstrates how an open constitutional approach to international law, including self-executing treaty provisions and the European Convention on Human Rights, enables courts to address issues of constitutional significance despite the formal prohibition of constitutional review.
Latvian and Dutch perspectives offer a separate yet convergent view on the interaction between national legal systems and EU law. The EU law principle of loyal cooperation has found its application in the recent case law of the Latvian Constitutional Court leading to protection of individual fundamental rights. The constitutional arrangements in the Netherlands offer a neighbouring perspective – Dutch openness towards international law, including EU law, offers practical solutions for safeguarding fundamental rights. The role of constitutional and supreme courts is best revealed in translating the international acquis for the benefit of the national legal order and offering effective judicial protection to its citizens.
The article concludes that the relationship between EU law and national law is not defined by hierarchy alone, but by cooperation, constitutional dialogue and mutual translation between legal orders. In this context, the Latvian and Dutch experiences show how national institutions of constitutional review may act as a hinge between domestic legal orders and the European legal space, safeguarding both the effectiveness of EU law and the protection of individual fundamental rights.
Published in: National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective. Proceedings of the 10th International Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Law of the University of Latvia, 6–7 November 2025. Riga: University of Latvia Press, 2026. ISBN 978-9934-36-688-8.