https://doi.org/10.22364/iscflul.10.07 | 89-103 | PDF

Indre Isokaite, Dr. iur., Associate Professor
Vilnius University, Faculty of Law, Lithuania

Protecting State’s Critical Maritime Infrastructure from Hybrid Threats

Key words: critical maritime infrastructure, State’s undersea infrastructure, undersea cables and pipelines, hybrid threats, shadow fleet

Summary
The article explores basic challenges of the law of the sea to protect critical maritime infrastructure from hybrid threats. The research aims at a comprehensive analysis of the rights and jurisdiction of a coastal state, a flag state and other states in each of maritime zones in the area of critical undersea infrastructure with the aim to identify difficulties to take measures in response to injuries of such infrastructure caused by “shadow fleet” ships and to propose possible solutions to address such risks. Measures which would be available or effective in such cases are limited because of the lack of regulation of undersea infrastructure in the 1982 Law of the Sea Convention, limited coastal states’ rights to board, intercept or start investigation in such cases beyond the limits of its territorial sovereignty, lack of suitable grounds in domestic law to be invoked in order to start and complete proceedings effectively, difficulties in establishing the violation and proving accountability, moreover, attributing it to a particular state, which in “shadow fleet” cases is often a flag of convenience, unwilling (or unable) to assume its flag state’s jurisdiction. Taking the complexity of the factors underpinning the cases of disruption of state’s critical maritime infrastructure and the limitations enshrined in the zone-based and jurisdiction-based character of maritime zones into account, the article concludes that the response should be multilayer, comprehensive and coordinated. Legal issues as regards developing proactive and unanimous interpretation of relevant rules and improving domestic legislation should go in hand with practical dimension – surveillance, trainings, military presence (deterrence), building resilience and strengthening protection. Coastal states should seek to invoke their prescriptive and enforcement jurisdiction to a maximum extent: in internal sea waters and territorial sea coastal states’ rights are widest as they derive from a territorial sovereignty, in the exclusive economic zone and the continental shelf sovereign rights apply in respect of underwater critical infrastructure and should be interpreted as allowing action in defined fields (navigation, environment), however, a coastal state does not have unlimited rights of interdiction, instituting proceedings and implementing accountability in respect of a foreign vessel the state of which in many cases related to the alleged injuries of undersea infrastructure holds primary jurisdiction. In addition, states may ground their rights on the articles providing for jurisdiction in cases of environment protection or rely on necessity. Action on a domestic level should be strengthened by international cooperation, processes and institutions that such international frameworks provide. At NATO, information sharing, trainings and overall deterrence shall be emphasized, although the alliance lists disruption of critical infrastructure among hybrid threats, which in an extreme case could even amount to consideration of invocation of a collective self-defence. At the EU, different measures aimed at capacity building and cooperation have been adopted for maritime security and protection of critical infrastructure in addition to application of sanctions. International Maritime Organisation explicitly indicated the threats posed by “shadow fleet” ships among global challenges to maritime safety and strengthening compliance with established shipping standards and the rules of jurisdiction is what must be further pursued. 


Published in: National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective. Proceedings of the 10th International Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Law of the University of Latvia, 6–7 November 2025. Riga: University of Latvia Press, 2026. ISBN 978-9934-36-688-8.