https://doi.org/10.22364/iscflul.10.06 | 75-87 | PDF

Andrzej Jackiewicz, Associate Professor
University of Bialystok, Poland

Constitutional Identity as a “Trap Card”: The Instrumentalisation of Article 4(2) TEU in the Jurisprudence of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal

Key words: constitutional identity, primacy of EU law, Polish Constitutional Tribunal, Article 4(2) TEU, rule of law, judicial independence, CJEU, legal dualism, sincere cooperation

Summary
This article analyses the evolution of the concept of “constitutional identity” in the Polish legal order in the context of the ongoing constitutional crisis. The main research objective is to demonstrate how the Constitutional Tribunal, through its judgments in cases K 3/21 and P 7/20, redefined this concept, transforming it from a shield protecting constitutional foundations into a tool for questioning the jurisdiction of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). The author advances the thesis that the Polish interpretation of constitutional identity deviates from the standards developed by constitutional courts of other Member States, notably the German Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG), insofar as it serves not primarily to protect immutable constitutional values, but rather to legitimise politically motivated changes to the judicial system. The article discusses the consequences of this approach, including the emergence of legal dualism and the erosion of the principle of sincere cooperation enshrined in Article 4(3) TEU. The analysis leads to the conclusion that the instrumentalisation of constitutional identity poses a real threat to the coherence of the European legal space and requires the development of new mechanisms for judicial dialogue between national constitutional courts and the CJEU.


Published in: National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective. Proceedings of the 10th International Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Law of the University of Latvia, 6–7 November 2025. Riga: University of Latvia Press, 2026. ISBN 978-9934-36-688-8.