https://doi.org/10.22364/iscflul.10.04 | 48-58 | PDF
Carri Ginter, Associate Professor
University of Tartu, Estonia
Katrine Plavina-Mika, LL.M. (Georgetown),
University of Latvia, Latvia
Applying EU Law in Pre-Accession Judgments in Estonia and Latvia
Key words: accession to the European Union, Europe Agreement, constitutional courts, Estonia, Latvia
Summary
This article examines whether, and in what ways, the highest Latvian and Estonian courts applied European Union (EU) law prior to their states’ accession on 1 May 2004. Three questions are explored here: (i) did the courts apply EU law before accession; (ii) what reasoning and legal methods enabled application; and (iii) do the relevant judgments reveal judicial activism.
Methodologically, the contribution compares all judgments of the national courts of final instance adopted between 1994 and 1 May 2004. For Latvia, this includes the Civil Law Department of the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court (established in 1996). For Estonia, the analysis focuses on the Supreme Court (Riigikohus) which combines final appellate jurisdiction (since 1919) and constitutional review (since 1993).
The authors of the current article find that the Estonian material demonstrates an unusually early and constitutionally anchored openness to EU law. In 1994, the Supreme Court’s Constitutional Review Panel (case No. III-4/A-5/94) interpreted Article 10 of the Estonian Constitution – an “open clause” recognising rights and principles deriving from the spirit of the Constitution and international law – to encompass general principles developed within European legal orders. This reasoning allowed the Court to discover general principles of EU law such as proportionality, legitimate expectations, and legal certainty in the Estonian legal system a decade before accession.
By 2003, the Estonian Supreme Court treated the Europe Agreement as functionally equivalent to EU Treaty obligations regarding the internal market. In case No. 3-3-1-68-03, it mirrored the freedom of establishment to criticise lower courts for excluding a branch of a company registered in the EU from public procurement. The Estonian Supreme Court also used the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights as persuasive authority in several 2003–2004 cases, drawing upon its codification of EU general principles of law to secure fair administrative procedure, the lex mitior principle, and minimum living standards, notwithstanding the Charter’s non-binding status at the time.
The authors find that Latvia followed a different trajectory shaped by constitutional continuity and the later creation of a specialised constitutional court. The reinstated Satversme (1922) and the delayed establishment of the Latvian Constitutional Court meant that a debate on EU-law methods emerged later. Early case law tried using comparative reasoning but a dissent in case No. 2000-03-01 urged fuller effect to Europe Agreement obligations. A clearer shift occurred by 2003, when the Latvian Constitutional Court began to treat EU-related norms as part of Latvia’s applicable legal framework via the Europe Agreement. In case No. 2003-08-01, it interpreted national rules on legal representation in light of EU law and free movement obligations, effectively identifying a de facto incompatibility with integration commitments and annulling the contested rules. In case No. 2002-18-01, the Court articulated its methodology, invoking association obligations and EU standards to critique and blanket ban on prisoner voting.
Thus, by 2003, both the Estonian Supreme Court and the Latvian Constitutional Court employed a monistic approach towards EU law, treating relevant EU norms and principles as part of the applicable legal framework. The categorical refusal to apply EU law to cases, where facts occurred before accession, by the Latvian Supreme Court is a contrasting example. That shines a light on the importance of institutional culture and constitutional jurisdiction in shaping judicial openness to EU law to help the new Member States succeed at EU integration.
Published in: National Legal Systems and the EU Law: Reality and Future Challenges in a Comparative Perspective. Proceedings of the 10th International Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Law of the University of Latvia, 6–7 November 2025. Riga: University of Latvia Press, 2026. ISBN 978-9934-36-688-8.